|
Caribbean People Commentary
January 1, 2007
Commentary Archives
Does corporal punishment work? A plethora of
Psychologist and children's organizations say no.
We are all familiar with the expression "Spare the rod and spoil the child."
This biblical passage has been
interpreted by many religious organizations, churches, and parents to suggest
that a good spanking is necessary for the proper rearing of children. After all,
it say so in the bible.
This interpretation of the scriptures, however, has
been under attack as a result of overzealous spanking or flogging of children,
which is seen as nothing more than child abuse.
Some sees the administering of corporal punishment as retribution,
frustration letting by adults, and among other thing, corporal punishment has been
linked to a kind
of sexual perversion.
There're two main facets to corporal punishment: a
form of punishment in the school and in the home, and a form of
punishment for committing crime. Our focused here is on children at school and
in the home.
Corporal Punishment in Schools
Some scholars say that in Proverbs
13-24, "Spare the rod and spoil the child." The word "rod," was translated from the Hebrew word "Shebet,"
which refers to the "authority of God" not corporal punishment.
Advocates of banning corporal punishment point to
statistics. These numbers show that between one and two thousand children die every year from
corporal punishment, 142,000 are seriously injured, and 1800 are permanently disabled.
In the face of these numbers, it's hard for the
advocates of corporal punishment to make a case that it has any disciplinary
benefit.
As a matter of fact they're drowned out by the
preponderance of notable organizations that opposes it.
To date Europe, Canada, Briton, and
Asia has banned corporal punishment. Going back to 2003,
some 28 States in The U.S had banned corporal punishment in schools. Those remaining are mainly in the southern
states. Public Opinion Despite this trend in outlawing of corporal punishment.
Public opinion in the U.S is split on the issue by a 49 to 46 percent in favor
of corporal punishment.
According to the American Academy of Pediatrics
"Corporal punishment is of limited effectiveness and has potentially deleterious
side effects."
It is believed that corporal punishment is
ineffective. Because usually it is handed out to repeat offenders. There's the belief that while the practice may
produce short-term results. In the long-term it increases the probability of
violence, resentment, and a desire to strike back. But it does not, in their
opinion, teach a child
appropriate behavior.
There're those who believe children that are spanked have, lower I.Q and
grow up to be domestic abusers. It has even been suggested by a German psychologist that sadism and machosim
develops from spanking of children. Sigmund Freud debunked this notion. Corporal Punishment in the Caribbean
In Barbados like much of the Caribbean, with some exceptions. (Trinidad and
Tobago banned corporal punishment in 2000). Corporal punishment in
schools and in the home is legal.
Parents, teacher, or lawful guardian of a child has the right under Bajan law
to administer corporal punishment. In schools and the home.
However, there're specific previsions for administering corporal punishment. It
must be carried out by
the head-teacher, or other authorized teachers. The punishment must be "moderate and reasonable using a proper
instrument."
Does Corporal punishment work
A survey of company CEOs found that while most say that spanking didn't play a role in their success.
Spanking taught them valuable life lessons.
Growing up in Barbados "Spare the rod and spoil the child" are the words I often
heard (coming from the mouth of my parents) right before the sting of the strap.
In school the head teacher would administer about three lashes with a leather
strap, from a face-to-face position to your back. In some cases to the palm of
the hand.
Towards a Passive Johnny
"...this is going to hurt me more than it will you." The loving application of
corporal punishment by parents have vanished. Amidst the ugly numbers of
violence against children, by vindictive parents, teachers, and religious
organization. Trying to beat the devil out of them.
Parents, against their best convictions can face criminal prosecution, for what
they might consider the best discipline for their kids.
The way we punish kids for infractions today, they're not likely to remember
what they were punished for.
Certainly, corporal punishment is not the only way to discipline a child, but
measure for measure, it sinks in.
We can all attest to the fact that there's is no punishment like that, that is predictable,
swift, and unrelenting.
They will remember the sting of the strap, and its association. Isn't this the
purpose of discipline?
I suppose this conditioning of the mind is what much of the fuss is about.
Coming from those who oppose any notion that there's benefit to corporal
punishment.
They have declared a war of
passivity against Johnny, against teaching our male kids strength of
character. Some where in all of this we've forgotten the importance of instilling a healthy
fear of God and respect for authority in our children. Are these much touted alternative forms of punishment really working? Look at
what's going on in our schools. It is the teachers that are afraid of the
students and the parents that have lost control of their children. Something
isn't working. |
|
You may use this material for Educational or other legitimate use under the "Fair Use Notice." Providing I'm given credit. |
Home | About this Site |
Preview Page | Photo Gallery | Philadelphia Page
| Caribbean Focus
| Good Books
Site Information
| Site map | New York City Page |
| Resources
| What's Happening
Contact us | Privacy policy
| Terms of use
| caribbean_interest_section | Commentary
|
Contact us
This Sites Design and up-keep, by Nigel Elcock